Traeger Pro 575 vs Pit Boss Pro Series 850: App Polish or Flame Searing
The Traeger Pro 575 and the Pit Boss Pro Series 850 own the midrange pellet grill conversation this season, from brisket forums to backyard group chats. One of them sears over open flame.
The Traeger Pro 575 lists at $799.99 and sells through local retailers across the country. The Pit Boss Pro Series 850 runs $599.00 at Lowe’s, its exclusive retail partner in the United States.
Both burn hardwood pellets, both connect to a phone, and both promise set-and-forget smoking through the whole night without a firebox to tend or a chimney to watch. That’s the split.
Traeger Pro 575: The App Runs the Cook

WiFIRE is the centerpiece here, pairing the D2 controller with the Traeger app so the grill joins the home network and takes temperature orders from a phone anywhere. The controller holds the set temperature with a variable-speed fan, a direct drive auger and a digital readout on the hopper. The phone becomes the control panel. A meat probe rides in the box and reports its readings into the same app. It’s family sized.
The barrel offers 575 square inches of total cooking space across two tiers of porcelain-coated steel cooking grates. It’ll hold 24 burgers at once. The two tiers let you run ribs up top and beans below. Porcelain coating keeps cleanup closer to a rinse than a scrape.
The temperature range runs from 165 to 500 degrees, hot enough for a weeknight pizza or a finishing sear on thick ribeye steaks. A cleanout door lets you swap pellet flavors between cooks without scooping out the old blend by hand or wasting what’s left. The hopper holds 18 pounds of hardwood pellets. At 124 pounds on all-terrain wheels, the grill moves around the patio and across the yard without a second pair of hands.
The recipe library is the quiet advantage, with more than 1,600 recipes carrying cook settings and probe targets. Step-by-step recipes send their settings and timing straight to the grill itself.
A first brisket follows a proven script instead of a guess, and that guidance shortens the learning curve for anyone new to pellet cooking. Owners build a library of their own cooks over time, saving the settings that worked and repeating them on the next brisket without notes on the fridge door. You won’t babysit this grill. That’s how a first pellet grill should feel. Traeger rates the barrel at 24 burgers, five rib racks or four chickens.
- Pro 575 maker list $799.99, sold through local retailers
- Pro 575 cooking space 575 sq in over two grate tiers
- WiFIRE app control with the D2 controller
- 18 lb hopper and a meat probe in the box

Pit Boss Pro Series 850: Built to Sear

The Pro Series 850 answers with 850 square inches of cooking area, split between a 593 square inch main grate and a 257 square inch upper rack above it. The main grids are porcelain-coated cast iron. That cast iron holds a sear.
A lever slides the Flame Broiler plate aside, and the fire pot’s open flame reaches the grids. Traeger sells no equivalent.
Controls run through a dial-in digital control board with PID temperature logic. The grill connects over WiFi and Bluetooth to the SmokeIT app, so every cook gets monitored from the couch or the garage. The temperature range spans 180 to 500 degrees, and the hopper holds 20 pounds of hardwood pellets. A removable ash system speeds cleanup after long smokes, and the grease path stays simple to manage.
A folding front shelf and a solid side shelf give you landing space for trays, tongs and a resting brisket. Together the shelves hold the tray, the tongs, the rub and the sauce without a side table. Locking casters plant the cabinet on the patio stones.
The eight-in-one pitch is versatility on paper. The hardware backs the important parts of it with cast iron, shelf space, ash management and that flame lever working as one system. Weekend cooks get a smoker that can finish steaks and still run a brisket overnight, a combination that’s rare at $599.00. Dansons backs it with a five year warranty on parts and electrical components. You’ll use the shelves daily. It’s built like patio furniture, not a toy.
- Pro Series 850 runs $599.00 at Lowe’s
- 850 sq in of cooking area, cast-iron main grids
- Flame Broiler lever for direct-flame searing
- 20 lb hopper and a five year warranty
Side by Side
The spec sheets tell the whole story in plain numbers. The numbers favor Pit Boss here. The cooking gap alone is 275 square inches, enough for a second brisket and a pan of beans.
| Product | Cooking Space | Grates | Temp Range | Hopper | App Control | Direct-Flame Sear | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Traeger Pro 575 | 575 sq in | Porcelain-coated steel | 165 to 500 °F | 18 lb | WiFIRE, Traeger app | No | 124 lb |
| Pit Boss Pro Series 850 | 850 sq in | Porcelain-coated cast iron | 180 to 500 °F | 20 lb | SmokeIT, WiFi and Bluetooth | Yes, Flame Broiler lever | 165 lb |
| App pick | Traeger Pro 575 | Porcelain-coated steel | 165 to 500 °F | 18 lb | WiFIRE, 1,600+ recipes | No | 124 lb |
| Sear pick | Pit Boss Pro Series 850 | Porcelain-coated cast iron | 180 to 500 °F | 20 lb | SmokeIT | Yes, Flame Broiler lever | 165 lb |
| Crowd pick | Pit Boss Pro Series 850 | Porcelain-coated cast iron | 180 to 500 °F | 20 lb | SmokeIT | Yes, Flame Broiler lever | 165 lb |
| Value pick | Pit Boss Pro Series 850 | Porcelain-coated cast iron | 180 to 500 °F | 20 lb | SmokeIT | Yes, Flame Broiler lever | 165 lb |
Price widens the gap further, since the Pit Boss undercuts the Traeger list price by $200.99 while offering the larger chamber and the sear lever. Traeger’s counter is software depth. That recipe depth is why Traeger owners tend to stay inside the brand when they upgrade.
More than 1,600 recipes in the Traeger app carry their settings straight to the grill. Both grills join WiFi and report to a phone, so connectivity ties, and the differences that count are physical ones you can touch and measure.
The Tradeoff

Pick the Traeger if the cook counts for more than the sear, because its app, recipe library and probe integration make long smokes genuinely hands-off. It’s also 41 pounds lighter.
Pick the Pit Boss if the patio hosts crowds, because 850 square inches and cast iron change what a weeknight cook looks like. The sear lever fixes the classic pellet grill weakness, the pale steak, for good. You give up some app polish, and you gain a grill that behaves like two separate appliances. The app gap is real, but it doesn’t erase 275 square inches of cooking space.
Verdict: Pit Boss Pro Series 850, by Space and Flame
The Pro Series 850 wins this pairing on cooking area, grate material and the direct-flame lever, and it does so at the lower street price. The Pro 575 remains the better buy for cooks who live in the app and smoke far more often than they ever sear.
- Pro Series 850 runs $599.00 at Lowe’s
- 850 sq in of cooking area, cast-iron main grids
- Flame Broiler lever for direct-flame searing
- 20 lb hopper and a five year warranty
Crowds settle it. Where to buy: Traeger retailers list the Pro 575 at $799.99, and Lowe’s sells the Pro Series 850 for $599.00 every day of the week.