Best Winter Gloves: Outdoor Research Warmth, Hestra Leather and Smartwool Merino

The Outdoor Research Alti II GORE-TEX Mitts, the Hestra Army Leather Heli Ski Glove and the Smartwool Merino Gloves split winter into three jobs. Prices run $27.95 to $208.95 at Amazon today.

Outdoor Research builds for expedition cold with a modular mitt and a removable liner. Hestra answers with goat leather and a guide brief, and Smartwool keeps the answer thin enough to live inside another glove.

One pick carries a discount at this check. The Smartwool pair sits at $27.95 against a $35.00 list figure, and the other two hold their standard prices.

Outdoor Research Alti II GORE-TEX Mitts: The Expedition Pick

Outdoor Research Alti II GORE-TEX Mitts shown from the back with the cuff closed

Outdoor Research fills the Alti II shell with PrimaLoft Gold at 170 g. The removable liner mitt carries 340 g of the same insulation, so the system stacks warmth in two layers rather than one thick wall. Moonlite Pile fleece lines the liner palms, and the whole mitt averages 364 g in a Large. The shell sheds weather.

A GORE-TEX membrane sits inside a 2.5 layer nylon ripstop face, and the Pittards Armortan leather palm takes rope and tool contact with Kevlar stitching at the seams. That palm is the durability story, because expedition mitts fail at the grip long before the insulation gives out on a cold route.

There’s a tradeoff, and it’s dexterity. A mitt this warm turns small buckles and stove valves into slow work, and the liner comes out for any task that needs bare fingers.

Outdoor Research Alti II GORE-TEX Mitts Men’s
  • GORE-TEX waterproof shell with a Pittards Armortan leather palm
  • PrimaLoft Gold insulation, 170 g in the shell and 340 g in the liner
  • Removable insulated liner mitt with Moonlite Pile fleece palms
  • Modular expedition mitt, 364 g average weight in Large
$208.95
Price at time of writing

Hestra Army Leather Heli Ski Glove: The Leather Guide Pick

Hestra Army Leather Heli Ski Glove pair showing the backhand and the leather palm

Hestra built the Heli Ski for ski guides in western Canada. Those guides needed a glove that survived long days of snow and cold without a lodge break, and the design has stayed close to that brief ever since. Army goat leather covers the palm and fingers, and a waterproof three layer polyamide fabric forms the backhand. Grip is the pitch.

G-Loft insulation warms the glove, the Bemberg lining removes for drying or swapping, and Eagle Grip construction shapes the fingers around a pole or a rope. A snowlock collar and a Velcro wrist strap seal the gauntlet, while the wrist leash and pinky eyelet keep a dropped glove hanging from your kit.

There’s a tradeoff, and it’s care. Leather asks for balm and drying time away from direct heat, and a fabric glove shrugs off neglect that shortens a leather pair’s working life.

Hestra Army Leather Heli Ski Glove 5-Finger
  • Army goat leather palm with a Triton polyamide fabric backhand
  • G-Loft insulation with a removable Bemberg lining
  • Snowlock collar, Velcro wrist strap and a wrist leash
  • Carabiner and hanging eyelet on the pinky finger
$184.95
Price at time of writing

Smartwool Merino Gloves: The Liner That Layers Under Everything

Smartwool Merino Gloves shown as a flat pair in black

Smartwool knits the Merino Glove from a lightweight Merino jersey on a nylon core. The jersey puts 100% Merino wool against your skin, so the glove regulates temperature and manages moisture while the nylon core gives the thin knit its working strength. Worn alone, it’s a cool weather glove for runs, dog walks and the drive to the trailhead in the early morning. Thin is the design.

The thumb and index finger carry touchscreen panels, so a phone comes out for a photo without bare hands meeting cold air at a windy overlook. Under a shell mitt, the same pair adds a warm, dry layer that slides in and out without bunching at the cuff or catching on a lining.

There’s a tradeoff, and it’s protection. The knit carries no shell and no insulation wall, so wind cuts through it on an exposed ridge and it can’t stand in for a ski glove.

Smartwool Merino Gloves
  • Lightweight Merino jersey fabric built on a nylon core
  • 100% Merino wool against the skin
  • Touchscreen compatible thumb and index finger
  • Thin liner that layers under a shell glove or mitt
$27.95$35.00
Save $7.05 (20%)
Price at time of writing

Side by Side

Hestra Army Leather Heli Ski Glove single front view with maker callouts for insulation and lining

Warmth splits this field first. The Alti II stacks two insulated layers for stationary cold at altitude. The Heli Ski pairs leather with a removable lining for working days, and the Merino Glove adds a thin layer that lifts any glove it sits inside.

Price spreads widest here. At $208.95 and $184.95 the two shells sit close, and the Smartwool pair undercuts both at $27.95 while asking a shell to finish the job on the coldest days of the season.

PickInsulationShellLiningPrice
Outdoor Research Alti II GORE-TEX MittsPrimaLoft Gold, 170 g shell and 340 g linerGORE-TEX 2.5 layer nylon ripstopRemovable liner mitt, Moonlite Pile palms$208.95 at Amazon
Hestra Army Leather Heli Ski GloveG-Loft synthetic insulationGoat leather with Triton polyamide backhandRemovable Bemberg lining$184.95 at Amazon
Smartwool Merino GlovesMerino jersey knit, uninsulatedMerino jersey on a nylon core100% Merino wool against the skin$27.95 at Amazon
Outdoor Research Alti II GORE-TEX MittsBest for expedition cold, belays and stationary work at altitude
Hestra Army Leather Heli Ski GloveBest for ski days, touring work and leather grip that lasts seasons
Smartwool Merino GlovesBest for layering under a shell and for mild days on their own

Each pick suits a different cold, so the choice comes down to the job your hands do most often. The two shells sit close at $208.95 and $184.95, while the Smartwool liner undercuts both at $27.95 and asks a shell to finish the job on the coldest days.

The Verdict

Smartwool winter lifestyle scene with a snowshoe group crossing open snow

Buy the Outdoor Research Alti II if cold leads. At $208.95 it’s the mitt for expeditions, bitter belays and anyone whose hands quit early in deep cold on long winter routes. The $208.95 price is the steepest here, and the bulk is the reason.

Choose the Hestra Heli Ski if leather leads. Goat leather, a removable lining and a guide grade build cover resort work and touring days at $184.95, with care as the running cost.

Pick the Smartwool Merino Gloves if layering leads. At $27.95 with 20% off the $35.00 list figure, they’re the cheap warmth upgrade that also covers mild days on their own.

Skip all three for wet spring slush at the resort. A lighter waterproof glove handles that brief better once the snow turns heavy and warm. Where to buy: each buying box above leads with the Amazon route on the gc01c-20 tag, then the maker link, at the prices checked today.