Best Smart Locks: Yale Codes, Schlage Home Keys and August Retrofit Ease
Three locks solve three different front doors here. The Yale Assure Lock 2 anchors the guide as the full replacement pick.
Renters keep their existing deadbolt with the August retrofit, while Apple households tap a phone against the Schlage and walk in. Every pick runs on built in Wi-Fi, so no hub joins the shopping list and no bridge hides in the fine print of any box below the fold.
Where to buy follows the door, the lease and the household phones, in that order.
Yale Assure Lock 2: The Full Deadbolt With Codes for Everyone

The Assure Lock 2 replaces the whole deadbolt. Keypad outside, thumb turn inside.
Entry runs four ways, and each one covers a different arrival home. A code opens the door at the keypad, and the Yale Access app opens it from anywhere with signal. An Apple Watch works right at the door. A physical backup key covers the day the batteries die at the worst possible moment.
Codes carry the daily load. Yale allows unlimited entry codes inside the app, and every code takes its own schedule. A dog walker gets Tuesday afternoons, and guests get a code that expires at checkout. Family keeps one permanent code that never changes unless someone revokes it.
Built in Wi-Fi talks to 2.4 and 5 GHz networks directly. Real time alerts land in the app when the door locks, unlocks or sits open.
DoorSense watches the frame rather than the bolt alone, confirming the door is fully closed before Auto-Lock secures it. Auto-Unlock reads your return and opens the door as you reach it with arms full. BHMA Grade 2 certification backs the hardware. Yale rates the lock from minus 22 degrees to 140 degrees outside, and low battery alerts arrive before the lock goes quiet.
The tradeoff is the install. Swapping a deadbolt takes longer than clipping on a retrofit, and renters need landlord approval first. At $179.90 against a $259.99 list, the current 31% cut pays for that extra hour without much argument.
- Keypad, app, watch and backup key entry
- Unlimited codes with schedules in the app
- Built in Wi-Fi on 2.4 and 5 GHz, no hub
- DoorSense with Auto-Lock and Auto-Unlock



Schlage Encode Plus: The Tap to Unlock Pick for Apple Homes

Schlage builds the Encode Plus around Apple home keys. An iPhone or Apple Watch taps the lock, the bolt turns, and the door opens. No code entry at all.
The Schlage Home app runs the rest of the system from the couch or the office. It holds 100 access codes, shows a full lock history and sends notifications each household member can shape. Built in Wi-Fi connects the deadbolt straight to the home network, for remote locking from anywhere the phone finds signal.
Security hardware runs deep here.
An encrypted connection guards the radio traffic, a built in alarm sounds on door movement or forced entry attempts, and the touchscreen resists fingerprints so a code stays hidden from anyone studying the glass. Schlage carries the highest residential BHMA rating for security, durability and finish on this deadbolt, and the Camelot trim in Satin Nickel suits traditional door hardware while Century trim covers modern doors.
Fit covers standard doors from 1-3/8 to 1-3/4 inches thick with a 2-3/8 or 2-3/4 inch backset. A screwdriver handles the install.
Price is the honest tradeoff on this pick. Amazon lists this finish at $284.97 with no discount running, and Schlage sells the lock from $329.00 in its own store. Apple households pay a premium for the tap. Android households hand that money to the Yale or the August and lose nothing at the door at all.
- Apple home keys, tap to unlock with phone or watch
- 100 access codes in the Schlage Home app
- Built in Wi-Fi and a built in alarm
- Highest residential BHMA rating



August Wi-Fi Smart Lock: The Retrofit That Keeps Your Keys

August takes the opposite route. The round unit mounts inside, over the existing deadbolt.
Outside hardware stays untouched, existing keys keep working, and the street facing side of the door looks exactly as it did before the box arrived. That approach wins rentals, design sensitive homes and any door where the brass already matches the house. August puts the install at about 10 minutes, the lock fits most single cylinder deadbolts, and removal at move out reverses the job with no holes to explain. Renters notice that difference first.
Built in Wi-Fi removes the bridge older August locks needed.
The app grants permanent, scheduled or temporary access to family, cleaners and dog walkers, and the Activity Feed logs each entry and exit with a time stamp attached. Face or fingerprint verification on the phone guards the unlock button itself, so a borrowed phone alone never opens the house.
Auto-Unlock uses geofencing to open the door as you arrive home, and Auto-Lock plus DoorSense secure it once it closes or after a set time. Voice control runs through Alexa, Google Assistant, Apple HomeKit and Samsung SmartThings, so the lock joins whichever system already runs the lights and the thermostat.
Codes are the gap. There is no keypad on the lock itself, so code entry needs the separate August keypad, and the original deadbolt carries the physical security rating rather than August. At $128.80 against $199.99, the 36% cut still makes it the cheapest route here by a wide margin.
- Retrofits over the existing deadbolt in about 10 minutes
- Keeps existing keys and outside hardware
- Built in Wi-Fi, no bridge needed
- Auto-Lock, Auto-Unlock and DoorSense



The Verdict and the Numbers Side by Side

Three doors, three answers. Pick the Yale for a full deadbolt replacement with unlimited scheduled codes and the strongest discount on a complete lock. Pick the Schlage when Apple home keys run the house and tap to unlock sounds worth a premium. Pick the August when the existing deadbolt stays, the landlord says no to hardware swaps, or the budget stops right at the door.
| Lock | Entry | Connection | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Yale Assure Lock 2 | Keypad, app, watch, backup key | Built in Wi-Fi, no hub | $179.90 |
| Schlage Encode Plus | Apple home keys, keypad, app | Built in Wi-Fi | $284.97 |
| August Wi-Fi Smart Lock | App, watch, existing keys | Built in Wi-Fi, no bridge | $128.80 |
| Yale Assure Lock 2 | Best for unlimited scheduled codes on a full deadbolt swap | ||
| Schlage Encode Plus | Best for Apple households that want tap to unlock | ||
| August Wi-Fi Smart Lock | Best for renters who keep their deadbolt and keys | ||
Every route here locks up behind you. Each one reports back to a phone, too.